| 1967 |
Ron McEachen |
First Team All-America |
| 1968 |
Pat Sullivan |
Third Team All-America |
| 1968 |
Len Forslund |
First Team All-South |
| 1981 |
Jon Capon |
First Team All-America |
| 2006 |
Nick Noble |
NSCAA/adidas First Team All-America |
| 2006 |
Jarrod Smith |
Soccer America First Team All-America |
| 1967 |
Walter Nistorenko |
Third Team All-America |
| 1971 |
Joe Okhakhu |
Honorable Mention All-America |
| 1973 |
Joe Okhakhu |
Honorable Mention All-America |
| 1974 |
Joe Okhakhu |
Honorable Mention All-America |
| 1972 |
Dennis Almeida |
Honorable Mention All-America |
| 1972 |
Manny Matos |
Honorable Mention All-America |
| 1973 |
Manny Matos |
Honorable Mention All-America |
| 1973 |
Jack Cardosa |
Honorable Mention All-America |
| 1981 |
Ashy Mabrouk |
Honorable Mention All-America |
| 2006 |
Andy Wright |
NSCAA/adidas Second Team All-Northeast Region |
| 2006 |
Jarrod Smith |
NSCAA/adidas First Team All-Northeast Region |
| 2005 |
Jarrod Smith |
NSCAA/adidas Second Team All-Mid Atlantic Region |
| 2006 |
Nick Noble |
NSCAA/adidas First Team All-Northeast Region |
| 2005 |
Devon McTavish |
NSCAA/adidas Third Team All-Mid Atlantic Region |
| 2006 |
Jarrod Smith |
M.A.C. Hermann Trophy Semifinalist |
| 1963 |
Joe Miller |
First Team All-South |
| 1967 |
Ron McEachen |
First Team All-South |
| 1967 |
Walter Nistorenko |
First Team All-South |
| 1968 |
Pat Sullivan |
First Team All-South |
| 1971 |
Joe Okhakhu |
First Team All-South |
| 1972 |
Joe Okhakhu |
First Team All-South |
| 1974 |
Joe Okhakhu |
First Team All-South |
| 1971 |
Manny Matos |
First Team All-South |
| 1973 |
Manny Matos |
First Team All-South |
| 1972 |
Dennis Almeida |
First Team All-South |
| 1973 |
Dennis Almeida |
First Team All-South |
| 1976 |
Roberto Calzadilla |
First Team All-South |
| 1980 |
Henry Long |
First Team All-South |
| 1980 |
Nigel Grosvenor |
First Team All-South |
| 1980 |
Jon Capon |
First Team All-South |
| 1981 |
Jon Capon |
First Team All-South |
| 1981 |
Ashy Mabrouk |
First Team All-South |
| 1990 |
John Keating |
Second Team All-South |
| 1983 |
Fernando Santos |
First Team All-South |
| 1992 |
Eric Beckner |
Second Team All-South |
| 1994 |
Mark Reilly |
Second Team All-South |
| 1967 |
Nick Ivahnenko |
Third Team All-South |
| 1963 |
Spike Hickman |
Third Team All-South |
| 1999 |
Craig Patton |
First Team all-BIG EAST |
| 1996 |
Riku Hirn |
First Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2006 |
Nick Noble |
First Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2006 |
Jarrod Smith |
First Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2006 |
Andy Wright |
First Team all-BIG EAST |
| 1995 |
Andy Leardini |
Second Team all-BIG EAST |
| 1997 |
Andy Leardini |
Second Team all-BIG EAST |
| 1998 |
Daniel Baleguero |
Second Team all-BIG EAST |
| 1999 |
Jared Feola |
Second Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2005 |
Nick Noble |
Second Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2005 |
Jarrod Smith |
Second Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2005 |
Andy Wright |
Second Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2004 |
Aaron Pitchkolan |
Third Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2005 |
Devon McTavish |
Third Team all-BIG EAST |
| 2006 |
Andrew Halsell |
Third Team all-BIG EAST |
| 1998 |
Chin Orih |
BIG EAST All-Rookie Team |
| 1999 |
Guido Cristofori |
BIG EAST All-Rookie Team |
| 2006 |
Andy Wright |
Preseason all-BIG EAST Team |
| 2006 |
Nick Noble |
BIG EAST Goalkeeper of the Year |
| 2008 |
Zach Johnson |
BIG EAST Goalkeeper of the Year |
| 2008 |
Zach Johnson |
First Team All-BIG EAST |
| 2007 |
Gift Maworere |
All-BIG EAST Honorable Mention |
| 2008 |
Gift Maworere |
All-BIG EAST Honorable Mention |
| 2008 |
Jason Bristol |
NSCAA Scholar All-East Region Honorable Mention |
| 2009 |
Zach Johnson |
College Soccer News Second Team All-American |
| 2009 |
Zach Johnson |
BIG EAST Preseason Goalkeeper of the Year |
| 2009 |
Zach Johnson |
All-BIG EAST Preseason Team |
| 1968 |
Walter Nistorenko |
Second Team All-America |