Players in the Pros
| Name | Team(s) |
|---|---|
| Herbert "Babe" Barna HoF | Philadelphia Athletics (AL) (MLB) 1937-38 New York Giants (NL) (MLB) 1941-43 Boston Red Sox (AL) (MLB) 1944 |
| Frank Barron | Washington Senators (AL) (MLB) 1914 |
| Vince Belnome | Tampa Bay Rays (AL) (MLB) 2014 |
| David Carpenter | Houston Astros (NL) (MLB) 2011-12 Toronto Blue Jays (AL) (MLB) 2012 Atlanta Braves (NL) (MLB) 2013-14 New York Yankees (AL) (MLB) 2015 Washington Nationals (NL) (MLB) 2015 Texas Rangers (AL) (MLB) 2019 |
| Gene Curtis | Pittsburgh Pirates (NL) (MLB) 1903 |
| George Freese | Detroit Tigers (AL) (MLB) 1953 Pittsburgh Pirates (NL) (MLB) 1955 Chicago Cubs (NL) (MLB) 1961 |
| Michael Grove | Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) (MLB) 2022 |
| Buck Guth | Minnesota Twins (AL) (MLB) 1972 |
| Jedd Gyorko HoF | San Diego Padres (NL) (MLB) 2013-15 St. Louis Cardinals (NL) (MLB) 2016-18 Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) (MLB) 2019 St. Louis Cardinals (NL) (MLB) 2019 Milwaukee Brewers (NL) (MLB) 2020 |
| Jim Heise HoF | Washington Senators (AL) (MLB) 1957 |
| Charles Hickman HoF | Boston Beaneaters (NL) (MLB) 1897-99 New York Giants (NL) (MLB) 1900-01 Boston Americans (AL) (MLB) 1902 Cleveland Broncos (AL) (MLB) 1902 Cleveland Naps (AL) (MLB) 1903-04 Detroit Tigers (AL) (MLB) 1904-05 Washington Senators (AL) (MLB) 1905-06 Chicago White Sox (AL) (MLB) 1907 Washington Senators (AL) (MLB) 1907 Cleveland Naps (AL) (MLB) 1908 |
| Joe Hudson | Boston Red Sox (AL) (MLB) 1995-97 Milwaukee Brewers (NL) (MLB) 1998 |
| Ed Kenna | Philadelphia Athletics (AL) (MLB) 1902 |
| Steve Kline | St. Louis Cardinals (NL) (MLB) 2002-04 Baltimore Orioles (AL) (MLB) 2005 San Francisco Giants (NL) (MLB) 2006 Cleveland Indians (AL) (MLB) 1997 Montreal Expos (NL) (MLB) 1997 Cleveland Indians (AL) (MLB) 1998-2000 St. Louis Cardinals (NL) (MLB) 2001 |
| Alek Manoah | Toronto Blue Jays (AL) (MLB) 2021-22 |
| Ryan McBroom | Kansas City Royals (AL) (MLB) 2019-21 |
| Larry McClure | New York Yankees (AL) (MLB) 1910 |
| John Means | Baltimore Orioles (AL) (MLB) 2018-22 |
| Harrison Musgrave | Colorado Rockies (NL) (MLB) 2018-19 |
| Dustin Nippert | Arizona Diamondbacks (NL) (MLB) 2005-07 Texas Rangers (AL) (MLB) 2008-10 |
| Paul Popovich HoF | Chicago Cubs (NL) (MLB) 1964, 1966-67 Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) (MLB) 1968 Chicago Cubs (NL) (MLB) 1969 Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) (MLB) 1969 Chicago Cubs (NL) (MLB) 1970-73 Pittsburgh Pirates (NL) (MLB) 1974-75 |
| Scott Seabol | New York Yankees (AL) (MLB) 2001 St. Louis Cardinals (NL) (MLB) 2005 |
| Kemper Shelton | New York Yankees (AL) (MLB) 1915 |
| Lewis O. "Bull" Smith | Pittsburgh Pirates (NL) (MLB) 1904 Chicago Cubs (NL) (MLB) 1906 Washington Senators (AL) (MLB) 1911 |
| William "Buck" Washer | Philadelphia Phillies (NL) (MLB) 1905 |
| Darrell Whitmore | Florida Marlins (NL) (MLB) 1993-95 |
| Fulton Woods | Boston Red Sox (AL) (MLB) 1924 |