| Season | Name | League | Team | Selection |
| 2019 | Nick Snyder | MLB | Arizona Diamondbacks | 11th round, 332nd overall |
| 2026 | Paul Schoenfeld | MLB | Arizona Diamondbacks | 8th round, 236th overall |
| 2002 | Billy Biggs | MLB | Arizona Diamondbacks | 40th round, 1,209th overall |
| 2002 | Dustin Nippert | MLB | Arizona Diamondbacks | 15th round, 459th overall |
| 1969 | Buck Guth | MLB | Atlanta Braves | 20th round, 468th overall |
| 2019 | Kade Strowd | MLB | Baltimore Orioles | 12th round, 348th overall |
| 1967 | Jerry Meadows | MLB (Sec) | Baltimore Orioles | 5th round, 101st overall |
| 2003 | Jarod Rine | MLB | Baltimore Orioles | 9th round, 254th overall |
| 1966 | Vaughn Kovach | MLB | Baltimore Orioles | 43rd round, 754th overall |
| 2014 | John Means | MLB | Baltimore Orioles | 11th round, 331st overall |
| 2001 | Shane Rhodes | MLB | Boston Red Sox | 11th round, 333rd overall |
| 1992 | Joe Hudson | MLB | Boston Red Sox | 27th round, 758th overall |
| 2025 | Skylar King | MLB | Boston Red Sox | 15th Round, 448th Overall |
| 1965 | Ron Renner | MLB | Chicago Cubs | 30th round, 600th overall |
| 1992 | David DeMoss | MLB | Chicago Cubs | 14th round, 387th overall |
| 1988 | Benny Shreve | MLB | Chicago Cubs | 34th round, 872nd overall |
| 2019 | Darius Hill | MLB | Chicago Cubs | 20th round, 612th overall |
| 1968 | Denny Taylor | MLB | Chicago Cubs | 24th round, 546th overall |
| 2008 | Josh Whitlock | MLB | Chicago Cubs | 26th round, 791st overall |
| 2007 | Levi Maxwell | MLB | Chicago White Sox | 18th round, 569th overall |
| 2018 | Jimmy Galusky | MLB | Chicago White Sox | 20th round, 588th overall |
| 2008 | Tyler Kuhn | MLB | Chicago White Sox | 15th round, 450th overall |
| 2019 | Ivan Gonzalez | MLB | Chicago White Sox | 8th round, 230th overall |
| 2011 | Grant Buckner | MLB | Chicago White Sox | 26th round, 801st overall |
| 1970 | Jim Mavroleon | MLB | Cincinnati Reds | 28th round, 662nd overall |
| 2022 | Trey Braithwaite | MLB | Cincinnati Reds | 16th round, 483rd overall |
| 1971 | John Hale | MLB | Cincinnati Reds | 19th round, 463rd overall |
| 2024 | Aidan Major | MLB | Cleveland Guardians | 5th Round, 146th Overall |
| 2001 | Matt Blethen | MLB | Cleveland Indians | 24th round, 727th overall |
| 1991 | Mike Moore | MLB | Cleveland Indians | 37th round, 970th overall |
| 2007 | Adam White | MLB | Cleveland Indians | 9th round, 287th overall |
| 1986 | Jeff Battaglia | MLB | Cleveland Indians | 15th round, 369th overall |
| 2007 | Tyler Kuhn | MLB | Cleveland Indians | 33rd round, 1,005th overall |
| 1990 | Darrell Whitmore | MLB | Cleveland Indians | 2nd round, 46th overall |
| 1993 | Steve Kline | MLB | Cleveland Indians | 8th round, 223rd overall |
| 2007 | Kenny Durst | MLB | Colorado Rockies | 15th round, 462nd overall |
| 1993 | Dan Barry | MLB | Colorado Rockies | 29th round, 828th overall |
| 2003 | Jason DiAngelo | MLB | Colorado Rockies | 27th round, 797th overall |
| 2014 | Harrison Musgrave | MLB | Colorado Rockies | 8th round, 233rd overall |
| 2019 | Sam Kessler | MLB | Detroit Tigers | 34th round, 1,012th overall |
| 1998 | Garrett Zyskowski | MLB | Houston Astros | 22nd round, 662nd overall |
| 2014 | Bobby Boyd | MLB | Houston Astros | 8th round, 226th overall |
| 2017 | Kyle Davis | MLB | Houston Astros | 15th round, 451st overall |
| 1967 | Jerry Meadows | MLB (Jan.) | Houston Astros | 4th round, 61st overall |
| 2016 | Chad Donato | MLB | Houston Astros | 11th round, 337th overall |
| 2026 | Maxx Yehl | MLB | Kansas City Royals | 3rd round, 91st overall |
| 2013 | Ryan McBroom | MLB | Kansas City Royals | 36th Round, 1,074th overall |
| 1991 | Dan Servello | MLB | Kansas City Royals | 28th round, 730th overall |
| 2016 | Blake Smith | MLB | Los Angeles Angels | 29th round, 876th overall |
| 2019 | Brandon White | MLB | Los Angeles Angels | 17th round, 511th overall |
| 2024 | Derek Clark | MLB | Los Angeles Angels | 9th Round, 262nd Overall |
| 1967 | Chuck Boggs | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 11th round, 220th overall |
| 2001 | Vance McCracken | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 18th round, 550th overall |
| 1965 | John Radosevich | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 5th round, 90th overall |
| 2025 | Robby Porco | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 13th Round, 405th Overall |
| 2021 | Adam Tulloch | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 17th round, 522nd overall |
| 2018 | Michael Grove | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 2nd round, 68th overall |
| 2021 | Madison Jeffrey | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 15th round, 462nd overall |
| 1991 | Mike Sube | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 40th round, 1,053rd overall |
| 1985 | Bob Tucker | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers | 27th round, 687th pick |
| 2015 | Taylor Munden | MLB | Miami Marlins | 27th round, 806th overall |
| 1997 | Steve Beller | MLB | Milwaukee Brewers | 25th round, 757th overall |
| 1971 | Rick Oliver | MLB (Jan.) | Milwaukee Brewers | 1st round, 17th overall |
| 2009 | Tobias Streich | MLB | Minnesota Twins | 5th round, 162nd overall |
| 1973 | Joe Honce | MLB (Jan.) | Minnesota Twins | 1st round, 12th overall |
| 1998 | Jamie Hammond | MLB | Montreal Expos | 23rd round, 684th overall |
| 2001 | David Maust | MLB | Montreal Expos | 17th round, 502nd overall |
| 2004 | Grant Psomas | MLB | New York Mets | 15th round, 434th overall |
| 1971 | Rick Wagener | MLB (Jan.) | New York Mets | 2nd round, 34th overall |
| 2018 | Kyle Gray | MLB | New York Yankees | 14th round, 427th overall |
| 1998 | Brad Elwood | MLB | New York Yankees | 19th round, 577th overall |
| 2014 | Sean Carley | MLB | New York Yankees | 14th round, 422nd overall |
| 2019 | Chase Illig | MLB | New York Yankees | 29th round, 885th overall |
| 2025 | Kyle West | MLB | New York Yankees | 13th Round, 404th Overall |
| 1998 | David Kloes | MLB | New York Yankees | 41st round, 1,237th overall |
| 2014 | Corey Walter | MLB | Oakland A's | 28th round, 852nd overall |
| 2022 | Jacob Watters | MLB | Oakland A's | 4th round, 124th overall |
| 1997 | Chris Enochs | MLB | Oakland A's | 1st round, 11th overall |
| 2025 | Logan Sauve | MLB | Oakland Athletics | 7th Round, 200th Overall |
| 2025 | Griffin Kirn | MLB | Oakland Athletics | 13th Round, 410th Overall |
| 2013 | Harrison Musgrave | MLB | Philadelphia Phillies | 33rd Round, 991st overall |
| 2001 | Josh Cisneros | MLB | Philadelphia Phillies | 23rd round, 680th overall |
| 2004 | Zac Cline | MLB | Philadephia Phillies | 15th round, 452nd overall |
| 1972 | Kim West | MLB | Pittsburgh Pirates | 13th round, 311th overall |
| 1966 | Doug Stanley | MLB | Pittsburgh Pirates | 25th round, 495th overall |
| 2023 | Carlson Reed | MLB | Pittsburgh Pirates | 4th Round, 104th Overall |
| 2009 | Vince Belnome | MLB | San Diego Padres | 28th round, 834th overall |
| 2021 | Jackson Wolf | MLB | San Diego Padres | 4th round, 129th overall |
| 2010 | Jedd Gyorko | MLB | San Diego Padres | 2nd round, 59th overall |
| 2013 | Sean Carley | MLB | San Diego Padres | 34th Round, 1,018th overall |
| 2021 | Ryan Bergert | MLB | San Diego Padres | 6th round, 190th overall |
| 1984 | Joe Filandino | MLB | San Diego Padres | 12th round, 299th overall |
| 2026 | Ian Korn | MLB | San Francisco Giants | 10th round, 298th overall |
| 2013 | Ryan Tuntland | MLB | San Francisco Giants | 29th round, 882nd overall |
| 2024 | Tyler Switalski | MLB | San Francisco Giants | 16th Round, 478th Overall |
| 1996 | Mike Riley | MLB | San Francisco Giants | 16th round, 462nd overall |
| 1989 | Steve Rolen | MLB | San Francisco Giants | 25th round, 648th overall |
| 2006 | Stan Posluszny | MLB | Seattle Mariners | 34th round, 1,011th overall |
| 1985 | Bob Bernardo | MLB | Seattle Mariners | 25th round, 633rd overall |
| 1966 | Jerry Meadows | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 23rd round, 447th overall |
| 2024 | J.J. Wetherholt | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 1st Round, 7th Overall |
| 1990 | Kevin Carpenter | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 23rd round, 623rd overall |
| 1996 | Scott Seabol | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 88th round, 1,718th overall |
| 1999 | Jeremy Cummings | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 21st round, 642nd overall |
| 2006 | David Carpenter | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 12th round, 376th overall |
| 2001 | Billy Biggs | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 36th round, 1,094th overall |
| 2026 | Dawson Montesa | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 2nd round, 72nd overall |
| 2002 | Joe Van Gorder | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 14th round, 432nd overall |
| 2022 | Victor Scott | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 5th round, 157th overall |
| 1987 | Ken Smith | MLB | St. Louis Cardinals | 30th round, 774th overall |
| 2018 | B.J. Myers | MLB | Tampa Bay Devil Rays | 35th round, 1,050th overall |
| 2024 | David Hagaman | MLB | Texas Rangers | 4th Round, 133rd Overall |
| 1986 | Bobby Watts | MLB | Toronto Blue Jays | 24th round, 620th overall |
| 2023 | Braden Barry | MLB | Toronto Blue Jays | 8th Round, 244th Overall |
| 1994 | Mark Landers | MLB | Toronto Blue Jays | 28th round, 791st overall |
| 2019 | Alek Manoah | MLB | Toronto Blue Jays | 1st round, 11th overall |
| 1985 | Rick Schlieper | MLB | Toronto Blue Jays | 20th round, 521st overall |
| 2014 | Ryan McBroom | MLB | Toronto Blue Jays | 15th round, 444th overall |
| 2017 | Jackson Cramer | MLB | Washington Nationals | 35th round, 1,063rd overall |
| 2015 | Blake Smith | MLB | Washington Nationals | 24th round, 734th overall |
143041,2019,MLB,11th round, 332nd overall367109,2026,MLB,8th round, 236th overall253455,2002,MLB,40th round, 1,209th overall92213,2002,MLB,15th round, 459th overall92021,1969,MLB,20th round, 468th overall142616,2019,MLB,12th round, 348th overall33258,1967,MLB (Sec),5th round, 101st overall92292,2003,MLB,9th round, 254th overall92110,1966,MLB,43rd round, 754th overall115967,2014,MLB,11th round, 331st overall253452,2001,MLB,11th round, 333rd overall92077,1992,MLB,27th round, 758th overall334953,2025,MLB,15th Round, 448th Overall92280,1965,MLB,30th round, 600th overall280337,1992,MLB,14th round, 387th overall92349,1988,MLB,34th round, 872nd overall117553,2019,MLB,20th round, 612th overall92409,1968,MLB,24th round, 546th overall92456,2008,MLB,26th round, 791st overall205829,2007,MLB,18th round, 569th overall115447,2018,MLB,20th round, 588th overall92112,2008,MLB,15th round, 450th overall117565,2019,MLB,8th round, 230th overall91889,2011,MLB,26th round, 801st overall92157,1970,MLB,28th round, 662nd overall289089,2022,MLB,16th round, 483rd overall624,1971,MLB,19th round, 463rd overall343727,2024,MLB,5th Round, 146th Overall253458,2001,MLB,24th round, 727th overall92186,1991,MLB,37th round, 970th overall92454,2007,MLB,9th round, 287th overall285341,1986,MLB,15th round, 369th overall92112,2007,MLB,33rd round, 1,005th overall802,1990,MLB,2nd round, 46th overall92103,1993,MLB,8th round, 223rd overall205802,2007,MLB,15th round, 462nd overall91848,1993,MLB,29th round, 828th overall91939,2003,MLB,27th round, 797th overall92198,2014,MLB,8th round, 233rd overall142585,2019,MLB,34th round, 1,012th overall92485,1998,MLB,22nd round, 662nd overall91881,2014,MLB,8th round, 226th overall115445,2017,MLB,15th round, 451st overall33258,1967,MLB (Jan.),4th round, 61st overall92518,2016,MLB,11th round, 337th overall335010,2026,MLB,3rd round, 91st overall92160,2013,MLB,36th Round, 1,074th overall92336,1991,MLB,28th round, 730th overall115439,2016,MLB,29th round, 876th overall142632,2019,MLB,17th round, 511th overall358447,2024,MLB,9th Round, 262nd Overall91873,1967,MLB,11th round, 220th overall253479,2001,MLB,18th round, 550th overall92269,1965,MLB,5th round, 90th overall334974,2025,MLB,13th Round, 405th Overall244378,2021,MLB,17th round, 522nd overall117552,2018,MLB,2nd round, 68th overall143089,2021,MLB,15th round, 462nd overall92400,1991,MLB,40th round, 1,053rd overall92426,1985,MLB,27th round, 687th pick158938,2015,MLB,27th round, 806th overall91857,1997,MLB,25th round, 757th overall92222,1971,MLB (Jan.),1st round, 17th overall203555,2009,MLB,5th round, 162nd overall92074,1973,MLB (Jan.),1st round, 12th overall92030,1998,MLB,23rd round, 684th overall253476,2001,MLB,17th round, 502nd overall92266,2004,MLB,15th round, 434th overall92439,1971,MLB (Jan.),2nd round, 34th overall117550,2018,MLB,14th round, 427th overall91963,1998,MLB,19th round, 577th overall92513,2014,MLB,14th round, 422nd overall117554,2019,MLB,29th round, 885th overall358443,2025,MLB,13th Round, 404th Overall92104,1998,MLB,41st round, 1,237th overall163927,2014,MLB,28th round, 852nd overall190012,2022,MLB,4th round, 124th overall91966,1997,MLB,1st round, 11th overall334982,2025,MLB,7th Round, 200th Overall362783,2025,MLB,13th Round, 410th Overall92198,2013,MLB,33rd Round, 991st overall253416,2001,MLB,23rd round, 680th overall91912,2004,MLB,15th round, 452nd overall783,1972,MLB,13th round, 311th overall1570,1966,MLB,25th round, 495th overall244370,2023,MLB,4th Round, 104th Overall91858,2009,MLB,28th round, 834th overall143045,2021,MLB,4th round, 129th overall92022,2010,MLB,2nd round, 59th overall92513,2013,MLB,34th Round, 1,018th overall143057,2021,MLB,6th round, 190th overall91979,1984,MLB,12th round, 299th overall367171,2026,MLB,10th round, 298th overall115943,2013,MLB,29th round, 882nd overall358442,2024,MLB,16th Round, 478th Overall261543,1996,MLB,16th round, 462nd overall92298,1989,MLB,25th round, 648th overall218252,2006,MLB,34th round, 1,011th overall91864,1985,MLB,25th round, 633rd overall33258,1966,MLB,23rd round, 447th overall289191,2024,MLB,1st Round, 7th Overall91899,1990,MLB,23rd round, 623rd overall92331,1996,MLB,88th round, 1,718th overall91925,1999,MLB,21st round, 642nd overall91898,2006,MLB,12th round, 376th overall253455,2001,MLB,36th round, 1,094th overall367203,2026,MLB,2nd round, 72nd overall92432,2002,MLB,14th round, 432nd overall189974,2022,MLB,5th round, 157th overall92364,1987,MLB,30th round, 774th overall115435,2018,MLB,35th round, 1,050th overall340251,2024,MLB,4th Round, 133rd Overall92446,1986,MLB,24th round, 620th overall244332,2023,MLB,8th Round, 244th Overall276811,1994,MLB,28th round, 791st overall142600,2019,MLB,1st round, 11th overall188672,1985,MLB,20th round, 521st overall92160,2014,MLB,15th round, 444th overall92517,2017,MLB,35th round, 1,063rd overall115439,2015,MLB,24th round, 734th overall